From the album Manning Fireworks
This is a song about accumulating ridiculous stuff to compensate for loneliness. Lenderman piles up absurd possessions (a beach home in landlocked Buffalo, a wristwatch that's somehow a megaphone) to prove he's doing fine, but every gadget just confirms what he already knows: he's alone and would trade it all for the person who thinks he's wasted his life.
So you say I've got a funny face / It makes me money
Lenderman takes an insult and spins it into a flex, but the flex is hollow. The money means nothing because the criticism came from someone whose opinion actually matters to him.
I got a beach home up in Buffalo / And a wristwatch that's / A compass and a cell phone
A beach home in Buffalo is geographically nonsense, which is the point. He's listing possessions that sound impressive but make no sense, matching how empty success feels when you're defending yourself to someone who's already written you off.
And a wristwatch that / Tells me you're all alone
The wristwatch suddenly stops being about navigation or communication and becomes a reminder of her loneliness. He's imagining she's as isolated as he is, which might be wishful thinking or just projection.
I'd still take your Amazing Grace / I'd give all my money / And I'd still take your pretty face
After all the defensive posturing, he admits he'd throw away everything he just bragged about. The repetition of "I'd still take" makes it sound like an offer she's already refused.
And a wristwatch that tells me / I'm on my own / And a wristwatch that tells me / I'm on my own
The wristwatch that was supposed to be a compass, a phone, a megaphone, all these tools for connection, just tells him he's alone. Repeating it drives home that no amount of stuff changes the fundamental truth.
The genius of this song is how it uses absurdist imagery (beach homes in Buffalo, watches that are megaphones) to make loneliness feel both ridiculous and crushing. Lenderman knows he looks like a joke, but he can't stop trying to impress someone who's already gone.