This is about someone bargaining their way into being loved. Every promise the speaker makes strips away another piece of themselves. What starts as self-sacrifice becomes self-erasure, and the tragic thing is they think wishing hard enough will change the odds.
Be good to me / Don't say what you don't mean
The speaker opens by requesting honesty but never asks for love. The bar is already on the floor. The best outcome they can imagine is not being lied to.
I'll sleep, I'll hide / To keep you in my life / I'll dream, I'll lie / To keep you on my side
Every verb describes disappearing. The speaker thinks devotion means making yourself small enough that the other person won't leave. The rhyme of 'life' and 'lie' lands hard because it reveals what this relationship actually costs.
My soil for your seed / Yes sir, no siege / I'm surrendered to your keep
The military language ('siege', 'surrendered', 'keep') frames love as occupation. 'Yes sir' is maybe the most devastating two words here because it makes submission sound like good manners. This is worship without a god who asked for it.
I'll speak, I'll howl / Arise like wildflower / I'll bleed, I'll bow / The show is over now
The speaker claims they'll 'arise like wildflower' and then immediately bleeds and bows. They might believe these are the same action. Growth and submission blur together when you've been performing devotion long enough that you can't tell the difference.
Wish on a star / Little light in the dark / Let it all reveal / What I always feel
Wishing on a star is what you do when you have no actual power. The speaker calls love 'sweet fortune' instead of using the word love at all, which reframes the whole song as gambling. You don't earn luck. You just hope it lands on you.
The saddest part is not that the speaker gives everything away. It's that they think magical thinking will work if they just wish hard enough. This is Silver Jews if David Berman had grown up watching rom-coms instead of reading poetry. You walk away knowing the star isn't going to answer.