From the album Let's Be Still
This is a song about the gap between wanting things to return to how they were and knowing they won't. The speaker keeps asking if we can go back while simultaneously insisting nothing will change, as if admitting the impossibility would make the loss too real. The whole thing reads like someone trying to comfort themselves into accepting a world that's already turned unrecognizable.
These are just flames / Burning in your fireplace / I hear your voice and it seems / As if it was all a dream
The speaker dismisses real sensory details as 'just' flames, then admits everything feels unreal. That move from minimizing to dissociating suggests someone who can't hold steady attention on what's in front of them because it hurts too much to fully see it.
Are we just like / Hungry wolves howling in the night / I don't want no music tonight
He pictures everyone as desperate, animalistic, then rejects the very act of making music while performing a song. The contradiction is the point: he wants silence but can't stop talking himself through the panic.
Every time I hear another story / Oh the poor boy lost his head / Everybody feels a little crazy / But we go on living with it
The 'poor boy' who lost his head might be someone else, might be himself. Either way, the response is the same resigned shrug: everybody's falling apart, everybody keeps going. That phrase 'living with it' does heavy lifting, turning survival into a low-grade chronic condition.
I'll tell you one thing / We ain't gonna change much / The sun still rises / Even with the pain
He frames 'we ain't gonna change much' as reassurance, but it's also a kind of defeat. The sun rising isn't hope so much as indifference: the world keeps turning whether we heal or not. This is what it sounds like when optimism and resignation occupy the same sentence.
Can we go on like it once was / Can we go on like it once was
He never answers his own question. Just keeps asking it, like repetition might eventually produce a different outcome. The speaker doesn't realize that the act of asking this many times already proves the answer is no.
This song doesn't resolve its own question. It just loops back to the beginning, asks again, and keeps going. That might be the most honest thing about it: sometimes you don't get closure, you just get used to the fact that things aren't what they were and probably never will be again.
Another Story by The Head and the Heart explores the tension between longing for the past and accepting that it cannot return, in Scalpel's line-by-line reading. The speaker repeatedly asks if things can go back while denying that anything will change, a contradiction that protects against fully confronting the loss. The song functions as a kind of self-comfort, a way of gradually accepting a fundamentally altered reality.
"Another Story" by The Head and the Heart explores asking questions you already know the answer to, nothing changes but everything's different, trying to comfort yourself into acceptance, and stories you don't want to hear. The central thread is asking questions you already know the answer to: The song circles around 'can we go on like it once was' without ever saying yes or no, as if asking repeatedly might change reality. These themes come from Scalpel's line-by-line analysis of the lyrics.
"Another Story" by The Head and the Heart was released on October 15, 2013 on the album "Let's Be Still". Scalpel's analysis covers the full lyrics of the 2013 release.
Scalpel's line-by-line analysis of "Another Story" by The Head and the Heart lands here: This song doesn't resolve its own question. It just loops back to the beginning, asks again, and keeps going.