From the album Potential - Single
This song is about mourning something that never actually existed. He's not grieving the relationship itself but the version of it he built in his head while it was happening. The real betrayal isn't that she left, it's that she stopped believing in the fantasy before he did.
Yeah, you hated how it looked off / But, baby, that's just how you grew up
He remembers her insecurity but frames it as something fixed, unchangeable, almost maternal in tone. This sets up the dynamic: he positioned himself as the one who could see her clearly, which makes her rejection of him feel like a rejection of reality itself.
There'll be someone new for you, baby / I'm not worried 'bout you, oh / I'll be somewhere going crazy / I'll be stuck on you
The reassurance collapses into obsession within four lines. He absolves himself by wishing her well, then immediately admits he'll be losing his mind. The contradiction is the point: he needs to believe he's moved on while proving he hasn't.
But I wrote some songs that got me famous / Sometimes I think about what it costs / You were the last one that I could trust
He built a career off the breakup but frames it as something that just happened, not a choice. Notice he doesn't say she was the last one he did trust, but the last one he could trust, like she took that capacity with her when she left.
And when I fall, I'm blaming you / That doesn't make it your fault / But it still makes it true
This is the song's thesis in three lines. He knows he's being irrational and insists on it anyway. The bridge abandons the pretense of moving forward and admits the whole song is just him assigning blame while acknowledging it doesn't belong to her.
I play alone in this game for two / You aren't the final boss, but you still make me lose
The video game framing is doing heavy work here. It reframes heartbreak as a winnable scenario where she opted out mid-playthrough. He's not even fighting her anymore, just stuck replaying levels by himself, which might be worse.
The song title is doing more work than it seems. 'Potential' sounds optimistic until you realize it's the past tense: we had it, and now it's gone, and he's stuck mourning a future that was never guaranteed. What he doesn't realize is that he might be more attached to the idea of being devastated than to who she actually was.